The Winners

Kelly Clarkson: Eating cake.

Ruben Studdard: Wishing he could afford to eat cake. And a 20 pound roast. And...

Fantasia Barrino: Plotting her revenge.

Carrie Underwood: Bathing in money.

Taylor Hicks: "You want fries with that?"

Jordin Sparks: Considering liposuction.

David Cook: Playing Casinorama. Again.

Kris Allen: Cursing the fickle gods of fate.
Other notables

Clay Aiken: Trying to remember where his pants are.

Bo Bice: Smashing his head into a wall repeatedly.

Chris Daughtry: Wondering why he didn't think of kissing a dude at the AMAs.

Katharine McPhee: Having "relations" with a hot blond babe. Well, at least that's what she's doing in my fantasy right now.

David Archuleta: Trying to stop his dad from beating him.

Adam Lambert: Realizing that all publicity is NOT good publicity.